Generated-UI design rubric

You can get a working page from an AI tool in minutes. Whether you should put it in front of customers is a design question, and this is a written way to answer it. It asks one question over the whole page, "Would you deliver this to a client as it stands?", then six checks, each graded from 1 to 5 with written anchors at 1, 3 and 5: hierarchy, layout and spacing, typography, colour and contrast, fit to the brief, and finish. Thirteen rules cover the cases that cause arguments, such as stand-in pictures and a page that runs off the side of a phone screen.

The repo holds the rubric, six frozen prompts (a coffee subscription page, an invoicing dashboard, a boot product page, a pricing page, an illustrator portfolio and a restoration article) and 24 outputs from five AI tools, each graded on all seven rows with the measured facts beside it: fonts in use, lowest text contrast, overflow at phone width and defect flags. There are no tool averages and no ranking.

The grades are an AI judge's. Rish Sadh reviewed 11 of the 24 and agreed with all of them. The other 13 are not reviewed. An AI agent ran the tools in his own logged-in browser, and some of those tools' terms forbid automated access. Six of the 30 planned slots are empty, and the README says why.